Swiss Center for Life Cycle Inventories. Another advantage is that the process produces a single score (Eco-Indicator Point) for the all the impacts of the product, not just individual ones for each part. Criteria for the selection and purchase of medical devices typically include safety for patients and staff, efficacy and ease of use, and purchase and handling prices. Safety Assessment of Di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP) Released from PVC Medical Devices. There could be hundreds of different sources for their materials. 15 - 21 Our group recently performed a life cycle assessment of anesthetic drug trays, finding that reusable trays were both environmentally and . Growing awareness of the negative impacts from the practice of health care on the environment and public health calls for the routine inclusion of life cycle criteria into the decision-making process of device selection. A complete life cycle cost analysis would complement the life cycle assessment results shown here; however, a simple analysis reveals that, assuming full utilization, a $200 reusable LMA costs $5 per use, plus $3 per cleaning for a unit cost of $8, excluding utility and hospital overhead costs. Overcash M. Comparison of reusable and disposable medical textiles. From the *Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, College of Engineering, Northeastern University, Boston, MA; School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, Yale University, New Haven, CT; Department of Anesthesiology, Yale School of Medicine/YaleNew Haven Hospital, New Haven, CT. Funding: Department of Anesthesiology, Yale School of Medicine. The life cycle impacts of the disposable and reusable LMA options are shown in Figure 2 for all impact categories, on the basis of data from Yale New Haven Hospital. BIC has repeatedly come under fire because of the environmental impact their disposable razors have, due to the sheer amount of their disposable products are used every year. A Life Cycle Assessment of Disposable Razors. One of their most popular products is the disposable razor, which they started to manufacture in 1975. However, BIC did report some of its transportation statistics. The tables didnt contain values for welding steel, so it has been assumed that the value is close to welding aluminium which is in the table. There are various ways that the product can get there. LCA is the most common tool for quantifying the environmental effects associated with a product, process, or service's entire life (Baumann and Tillman 2004).LCA was performed in accordance with the international standards of the ISO 14040 and ISO 14044 . Conducting a Life Cycle Assessment (LCA): from Theory to Practical BIC says its product beats out other models by 59 percent. Sinha R, Sunder R. Retiring reusable laryngeal mask airways after 40: an anaesthetist's dilemma. Life Cycle Assessment - definition & methodology. Finally, inclusion of the environmental impacts of labor for cleaning (from wages spent on goods and services) only nominally increases the total GHG and water impacts of reusable LMAs. A comparative cradle to grave life cycle assessment (LCA) was conducted to determine and analyze the environmental impacts of using disposable acrylic speculums versus using reusable stainless-steel speculums in a women's university health clinic where around 5,000 pelvic exams are conducted on a yearly basis. LCAs can be used comparatively to assess different product or service design options or to identify environmental . qILL@#nO @8
h[K#1}\$u@ Interpretation of results The last step in the process is to interpret the results and compare them against each other. This practice meets American Society of Anesthesiologists' recommendations for infection control for equipment requiring high-level disinfection.14. associated with the environmental interventions attributable to the life-cycle of a product. What Is Polystyrene? Life Cycle Assessment of the Closed-Loop Recycling of Used Disposable After the end of their recommended lifetime, reusable LMAs were also placed in municipal solid waste containers. This was a cradle-to-grave study that included inputs and outputs for the manufacture, transport, use, and waste phases of the LMAs. The total amount of direct GHG emissions in 2016 was estimated at 8,689 teqCO2, i.e. 1.Establish the purpose of the Eco-Indicator calculations The human-health-related impact categories are pertinent to those developing standards for the delivery of health care. A Life Cycle Assessment of Reusable and Single-Use Central V - LWW Steel Life Cycle.SSAB, www.ssab.com/company/sustainability/sustainable-offering/steel-life-cycle?di=discover21C927E58ECC41198B78D915F7E3E2AF. Please try again soon. Dbendorf, Switzerland, 2011, 12. So, while this solution is not an easy fix, as it would require buyers to save their own waste, it does provide an alternative to the disposable razor waste crisis. In this post I havent shown the whole process, but there are downloadable links to my full Eco-Indicator results, and to the template form if youd like to carry out an assessment yourself. 3 in Table 1). Anesthesiology 2003;99:1066, 6. 2.Define the life-cycle . A life-cycle assessment or LCA is a 'cradle to grave' analysis of the impact of a manufactured product on the environment. The LCA is broken into four stages: Defining the goal and scope how much of a product's lifecycle will be addressed, the reasons for carrying out the assessment, the intended audience, and the intended end-use [] Polypropylene. Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 30 Nov. 2019, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polypropylene. What's the greenest way to shave? - Slate Magazine To bring the metal to its final form, it is heated to extremely high temperatures to remove the binders, and to mold the metal particles together, in turn, creating a very strong and durable metal compound (Siddle, How Is Tungsten Carbide Formed?). In order to carry out the Eco-Indicator analysis method, the methodology described below has to be followed: 1.Establish the purpose of the Eco-Indicator calculations 2.Define the life-cycle 3.Quantify the materials and processes 4.Complete the form 5.Interpret and analyse the results Environment Agency (Life Cycle Assessment of Disposable and Reusable Nappies in the U.K.) investigated the impact of three diapering systems: cloth diapers with home wash, cloth diapers with commercial laundry, and disposable diapers. These impacts are quantified here in terms of energy use, water use, and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions using general factors for US labor.22. During shaving, the sharp edges of the blade will chip off at a slow but steady rate, dulling the blade after repeated shavings. After reaching the end of their useful lives, both LMAs and their respective packages entered waste management, which was modeled using US average statistics on recycling/composting, landfilling, and incineration.15 Although some incineration facilities also produce electricity, this credit is not included here. Bic has attempted to lower their direct emissions by having factories world-wide and creating: a Transport Community which connects shipping managers on each continent to raise control for greenhouse gas emissions, optimize shipments and routes, and use only responsible carriers (Bic). J Environ Assess Policy Manage 2000;2:45376, 2. Saudi J Anaesth 2008;2:58. Life Cycle Assessment Explained - STiCH Define the Life-cycle This is an example of a simple product life-cycle diagram. climate change, summer smog, resource depletion, acidification, human health effects, etc. Nash, Nathaniel C. HOW BIC LOST THE EDGE TO GILLETTE. The New York Times, The New York Times, 11 Apr. Figure: Life Cycle Assessment steps: goal and scope definition, life cycle inventory, life cycle impact assessment and interpretation (Sala et al., 2016) In the goal and scope phase, the aims of the study are defined, namely the intended application, the reasons for carrying out the study and the intended audience. To make the handle and cartridges, these various plastics are heated together and melted together along with optional colorants and various filler materials. Life cycle assessment of a disposable and a reusable surgery instrument set for spinal fusion surgeries Leiden A, Cerdas F, Noriega D, Beyerlein J, Herrmann C. Life cycle assessment of a disposable and reusable surgery instrument set for spinal fusion surgeries. Facilities that select reusable devices should implement inventory and operating procedures that ensure that devices are reused to the greatest possible extent. Disposable razors are a commonly used item for most Americans, and over two billion razors are thrown away every year in the United States (Shabecoff). Several waste management scenarios were also considered, including 100% landfilling and 100% incineration, because practices are highly location dependent. The metal is then heated and then cooled slowly to remove any internal stress, which makes it tougher, this process is called annealing (Safety Razor). Life Cycle Assessments - Diaper Answers Flying staff to meetings, shipping, and distributing the product is the highest offender for the planet. The largest difference in environmental impacts is seen in the impact category of carcinogenesis, in which reusable LMAs cause 5% of the impacts of disposable LMAs. Life Cycle Assessment - IPP - Environment - European Commission xTkJ((5:Ome\%{yIlka;K=1 Disposable Razors at Best Price in India - IndiaMART PDF An updated lifecycle assessment study for disposable and reusable nappies Brimacombe J, Keller C, Morris R, Mecklem D. A comparison of the disposable versus the reusable laryngeal mask airway in paralyzed adult patients. Differences in environmental impacts between devices may present a compelling consideration in their selection. There is also an additional resin called fluorine resin that is applied to the blades, which allows them to freely glide on the skin. The actual making of the razors, and printing paper for their packaging has a lower environmental impact, than the waste from the factories high energy use. However, the viability of the disposable razor is always thrown into question because of the sheer amount of resources that it expends. The main causes of the reusable LMA's environmental impacts are the steam used in the autoclave sterilizing machine and, to a lesser extent, the wastewater generated from washing the LMAs. Ask a worker if you can put them in the bin by themselves or if they need to be in a recyclable container to protect sanitation workers from being cut. The carbon footprint reported was separated into two sections which are direct and indirect emissions. GaBi includes its own database containing life cycle inventories of processes such as polypropylene manufacturing, transportation, and landfill . To create the metal compound, carbon is added to the purified tungsten in a complex chemical process where the materials are heated to over 2,200 degrees celsius. Life Cycle Assessment of Compostable Coffee Pods: A US - Nature Upgrading to a new, energy-efficient autoclave machine leads to a nearly equal reduction in life cycle GHG emissions and may be considered particularly in instances in which older equipment is being used. Address correspondence to Jodi Sherman, MD, Yale University, School of Medicine, Department of Anesthesiology, 333 Cedar Street, TMP3, New Haven, CT 06520. A life cycle assessment or analysis according to ISO 14040/14044 is an instrument of environmental and sustainability management. How Long Will It Take That Bag of Trash to Decompose in a Landfill?The Balance Small Business, The Balance Small Business, 22 Oct. 2019, www.thebalancesmb.com/how-long-does-it-take-garbage-to-decompose-2878033#plastic-waste. Anesth Analg 2004;99:6267, 17. Such an analysis is commonly performed using life cycle assessment. The indirect emissions were mostly from the electricity use in the factories. The more capital-intensive option of increasing the energy efficiency of the autoclave machines by 10% decreases GHG emissions by 8%. Chu L, Mathur P, Trudell J, Brock-Utne J. LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT: PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE | Science Inventory - US EPA By raising awareness and creating locations where one can drop off used razors for recycling, perhaps a change can come. 39 ($0.37/Count) FREE delivery Thu, Mar 2 on $25 of items shipped by Amazon. Clean Edge, Non Disposable razor case study analysis - SlideShare 85 percent of the energy came from electricity, 14 percent came from gas, and the rest came from fuel oil (For You For Everyone Registration Document). There are 3 key tasks in this step. Disposable razors are a product that can be found in almost any average bathroom. Int J Life Cycle Assess 2001;6:7680, 13. Polypropylene is recyclable with the resin code of 5, which is its numbered identification code that is used to identify what resins plastic products are made of, and indicate how they are recycled. International Sympsium on Sustainable Systems and Technology. I could however not find any details about the energy consumption of the machines used in the assembly process. Gillette Mach3 Disposable Razors for Men, 6 Count, Designed for Sensitive Skin. Main methodological choices . To start the process of making the blades, tungsten carbide is melted at high temperatures. Gillette Mach3 Men's Disposable Razor for Sensitive Skin - Best Cartridge Razor for Sensitive Skin. Data Uncertainty. Until now, we defined what we want to measure and collect in phase 1. Washington, DC: U.S. Bureau of Transportation, 2002, 14. (PDF) Sources, Fate and Effects of Microplastics in the Marine Life cycle assessment (LCA) is a method used to estimate the total environmental impacts from producing a good or service. Disposable Razors in Bulk, Bulk Razors with Knife Caps, Individually Packaged Disposable Razors Bulk, Suitable for Hotels, Shelters, Homeless People, Nursing Homes, Charities, Churches (60) 4.2 4.2 out of 5 stars (9) $22.39 $ 22. An exact number for the energy use for BIC was not obtained. The buyer online is not exposed to the long lasting waste of the razors after they are thrown out. An estimated 1 L of tap water was used to wash and rinse 1 LMA (or 40 L over a lifetime of 40 uses). The laryngeal mask airway (LMA) was introduced into clinical use in the late 1980s and approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for use in the US in 1991. How Is Tungsten Carbide Formed? Chronicle, 20 Aug. 2015, chronicle.kennametal.com/how-is-tungsten-carbide-formed/. In this paper, many details about the life cycle stages were not included. Here's How to Keep Your Razors from Contributing to Landfill Waste. USA Today, Gannett Satellite Information Network, 7 Aug. 2019, https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2019/08/07/landfill-waste-how-prevent-disposable-razor-plastic-pollution/1943345001/. But this is expected from a large brand like Gillette. Manufacturing Processes (RAZOR): KAI FACTORY: KAI Group. KAI FACTORY | KAI Group, www.kai-group.com/global/en/kai-factory/process/razor/. Two Life Cycle Impact Assessment (LCIA) methodologies were employed using SimaPro software 51,52 to calculate the environmental impacts of manufacturing both the plastic and compostable coffee . Teoh W, Lim Y. What Is Tungsten Carbide or Hard Metal? AZoM.com, 2 Aug. 2009, https://www.azom.com/article.aspx?ArticleID=4827. : Uses, Benefits, and Safety Facts.ChemicalSafetyFacts.org, 17 June 2019, www.chemicalsafetyfacts.org/polystyrene/. LCA can be used to compare alternative products, processes or services; compare alternative life cycles for a certain product . Life Cycle Assessment: Biopharma SUTs - BioProcess The majority (77%) of life cycle CO2e emissions for the reusable LMA is from natural gas production and combustion to produce steam for the autoclave machine. Phenylene oxide, or PPO, is another common plastic material used in disposable razors. Cited Here. It is at this stage that very small amounts of other metals such as iron, silicon, and chromium may be added to the carbide to increase its strength and durability. 1. Next, the razors will be tested for flaws, strength, and razor hardness and sharpness (Safety Razor, madehow.com). use/disposable and multiple-use/washable surgical gowns. The metal and plastic components of the cartridges will be assembled, where they will then go to the next station where the blades will be inserted. Assessing all steps in that life cycle provides insight into individual stresses and burden shifts from one step to another and enables understanding of both the cumulative environmental impacts and related trade-offs in each area, throughout the lifespan of both a facility and its manufactured products. For You for Everyone Registration Document. Packaging is an . The blades, which are made from a carbide steel made using tungsten carbide, the handle, which is made from a combination of plastics such as polypropylene, polystyrene, and phenylene oxide (PPO), and the cartridge, which is made up of these plastics and sometimes the carbide steel as well (Safety Razor, madehow.com). In phase 3, we evaluate how significant the impacts are. What Is Tungsten Carbide?" The data collected through LCA helps organizations make conscious decisions that affect the environment. GaBi is a LCA software that allows its users to connect environmental impacts to a product across its lifespan. Life Cycle Assessment - GDRC It can be used to study the environmental impact of either a product or the function the product is designed to perform. We can see how the double edge safety razor has a much lower impact due to the low amount of parts and materials used and the fact that the blade can be separated from the rest of the body and recycled (reducing the overall impact of the product). . A major flaw in the disposable razors design is in fact its inability to be sustainably and properly disposed, despite what its name suggests. Life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) covers all relevant inputs from the environment (e.g., ores and crude oil, water, land use) as well as emissions into air, water and soil (e.g., carbon dioxide and nitrogen oxides). Table 2 shows the results of alternate assumption on the overall results. The majority of life cycle human health impacts of disposable LMAs are caused by PVC use in packaging and the device itself. Ans: (i) Significant growth in industry of super premium segment . PPO elements of the disposable razor are hard to determine in years, however, data shows that most plastic items take up to 1,000 years to begin to decompose (LeBlanc). There are three main materials used in the plastic handle and the cartridge of the disposable razor. Finally, the assessment will be carried out on the new design to assess if it has a lower impact than the other options analysed. The plastic handle and head of the disposable razor consists of a hybrid of polypropylene, polystyrene, and phenylene oxide, also known as PPO. Sensor3 disposable razors for men feature an enhanced Lubrastrip with water activated Comfortgel technology for ultra-gentle shaving on your sensitive skin. Siddle, Dave. #4. Environmental Life-Cycle Assessment of Disposable Bioreactors - BioProcess InternationalBioProcess International Upstream Processing Bioprocessing begins upstream, most often with culturing of animal or microbial cells in a range of vessel types (such as bags or stirred tanks) using different controlled feeding, aerating, and process strategies. RSA
The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica. Yet, as they are designed to be thrown away after use, a question is raised of their fast accumulating waste and its impact on the environment. It is resistant to fats and almost all organic solvents which helps it hold up in the damp and warm conditions of a bathroom and shower (Polypropylene. Wikipedia.org). The metal is heated to a temperature of 1967-2048 degrees Fahrenheit and tungsten carbide has a specific heat of 0.226 BTU/lb/Fahrenheit (Safety razor). Disposable LMAs are made largely from PVC plastic, which is associated with a number of health concerns that are gaining increased attention.23 Historic efforts to minimize routine medical incineration resulted in the 1998 Memorandum of Understanding between the American Hospital Association and the US Environmental Protection Agency, largely on the basis of recognition of the potential carcinogenic effects of burning PVC plastics. Despite the overall lower impacts of the reusable LMA, there are still several ways that its environmental profile could be improved, as suggested by the results shown in Table 2. Small components such as inks and labels on the packaging and on the sterilization indicator strips are expected to have negligible impacts and were excluded from the analysis. 2011, Packaging Technology and Science. An LCA is a life cycle assessment which is completed through research, testing and understanding of the environmental impacts a particular item creates through it's resources use/ production/distribution/disposal. The life of a typical razor blade is not an easy one. Reusable LMAs were collected in a dirty device bin on the anesthesia cart and then reprocessed by the anesthesia technicians. Considering human health concerns, the majority (60%) of impacts for the disposable LMA is due to the production of polymers, PVC in particular, with emissions from incineration contributing another 15%. DEHP leaches out upon exposure to heat and lipids, as would be the case in contact with mucous membranes. How Does Polystyrene Recycling Work?HowStuffWorks Science, HowStuffWorks, 4 Apr. The metal is then quenched in water to bring it to -76 to -112 degrees Fahrenheit to harden the material (Safety Razor). On the basis of information provided by the distributing company, the disposable LMA was manufactured in Hangzhou, China, and the reusable LMA was manufactured in Singapore. It is used in razor manufacturing mainly due to its high heat and water resistance, making it ideal for the conditions the product is used in. Life Cycle Assessment: Disposable paper cups by Shanice Robbins Highlights Decision makers have typically favored disposable LMAs because the purchase price is perceived to be less for a comparable quantity of disposable LMAs, in comparison with 1 reusable LMA with its associated labor costs for in-house reprocessing.6. This manuscript was handled by: Steven L. Shafer, MD. The EPA has now stopped tracking the: impact of disposable razors on the environment and has no update on the figure (Olsen). How One Facility Completely Eliminated the Use of TCE Schick Razor Blade Manufacturing in Knoxville, Tennessee. 2017. Polycarbonate production (14%), transportation via truck (15%), thermoforming (13%), and waste disposal (11%) cause the majority of the remaining emissions. Safety Razor. How Products Are Made www.madehow.com/Volume-5/Safety-Razor.html. Contact Supplier. No such cases have been reported since 1976.a There is no reported case of iatrogenic infection of any type linked to a reusable LMA. In landfilling or incinerating this part, the large amount of energy and material value used in creating it is lost. Kaplan, Desire. However, because of the new awareness to their wasteful impact on the environment, some companies have begun to provide solutions to the disposable razor issue. Policy H-135.945: Encouraging Alternatives to PVC/DEHP Products in Health. This reflects the equivalence between 40 disposable LMAs and their associated materials, waste, and 40 uses of 1 reusable LMA. Life cycle analysis takes into account the following categories: Energy consumption Water consumption Air emissions (including carbon dioxide and other global warming gases) Water emissions Generation of solid waste Life cycle assessment - Environmental Assessment and Optimization Group Environmental LCA - Life Cycle Initiative Once Terracycle has collected the waste, it is: broken down and separated by material. Anesth Analg 1993;77:1079, 21. Address e-mail to [emailprotected]. The life cycle assessment results shown here allow clinicians and health care administrators to understand the balance between direct benefits of a given LMA choice to local patient care and the environmental and human health impacts of that choice that occur far from the operating room. The largest source of GHG emissions for the disposable LMAs (23%) is the production and polymerization of PVC, the main material constituent. The following document provides an introductory overview of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and describes the general uses and major components of LCA. The company reported that with their hazardous waste in 2016 11 percent was recycled, 49 percent incinerated with energy recovery, 8 percent sent to land disposal, and 32 percent was sent off to be treated in another way (For You for Everyone Registration Document). In this case it was very difficult to see what materials the product contained and exactly how it was manufactured (as the big manufacturing companies wouldnt disclose this information), so some of the data had to be assumed. In life cycle assessment, the basis of comparison is called the functional unit. For this report, the functional unit of the disposable and reusable LMAs was taken to be maintenance of airway patency by 40 disposable LMAs or 40 uses of 1 reusable LMA.9 Data collection was specific to Yale New Haven Hospital, including device transportation, cleaning procedures and labor, energy requirements, and disposal. endstream
endobj
752 0 obj
<>stream
The blades and lubricating strip were too light to be measured with our equipment so their weights were rounded to 1g. The authors declare no conflict of interest. Technical Fact Sheet-Tungsten.Technical Fact Sheet- Tungsten, EPA, Jan. 2014, www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2014-03/documents/ffrrofactsheet_contaminant_tungsten_january2014_final.pdf. BIC Group, 2016, Sustainable Development Report. For me, I had a few extra bits of plastic that I snapped off because they . We purchase the product in a store, use the product for removing unwanted body and facial hair until it eventually dulls, and then we toss it in the bathroom trash, unaware of where it goes or where it came from. The alloy must allow for easy manufacturing due to the high demand of disposable razors and enough strength to last through transportation and shelf holding. Sets Strategy to End 'Staggering' Garbage Crisis.The New York Times, The New York Times, 23 Sept. 1988, www.nytimes.com/1988/09/23/us/epa-sets-strategy-to-end-staggering-garbage-crisis.html. What does a business area's assessment of agreements, income, and value implicate? BIC has noted however that they strive to be as efficient with materials used when it comes to their packaging. The specific type or blend of plastic for BIC razors is used is called polystyrene (Europe). This is based on our Life Cycle Inventory flows from phase 2. BIC Comfort 3 Refillable Three-Blade Disposable Razors for Men, Sensitive Skin Razor for a Comfortable Shave, 1 Handle and 12 Cartridges With 3 Blades, 13 Piece Razor Kit. Tungsten is a natural metal deposit that is found in metamorphic, and granitic igneous rocks, primarily in China, Russia, South Korea, South America, and the Rocky Mountains in the United States. Then we collected and structured the data in phase 2. Bics direct emissions were from: a combustion of fossil fuels, primarily natural gas and fuel oil, mainly used to heat buildings. %PDF-1.5
%
The LMA, within the heat seal pouch, was then placed in the steam autoclave sterilizing machine (Castle/Getinge MC 3522). (ii)Access paramount's competitive position? J Clin Anesth 1997;9:432, 20. In addition, although this life cycle assessment study did not analyze health impacts during use of an LMA, intraoperative exposure to diethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP) is of some concern. 13, 14 There are few published life cycle assessment studies of medical items (ref. These few simple materials go through processes of heating, cooling, moulding, cutting, and sharpening throughout their manufacturing process to eventually become the handle, razor blades, and blade cartridge, that will then be assembled to become a disposable razor.